Natasha's Flowers - a Gaza story

Natasha Boon and her colleagues run a flower stall close to Kentish Town Station. The last few months have not been easy for them: the tube station has been closed for escalator replacement, and by the time it re-opens in (cross fingers) September we will have been tubeless for a year. Their trade has suffered accordingly.

But last week a new disruption arrived, in the form of a protest for the week set up by the Palestinian Solidarity Group under the banner 'Gaza Week Camden'. Why Kentish Town, an area not known for a significant Jewish presence? The answer lies less than 10 minutes walk away, Keir Starmer's home, so perhaps a case of get your pressure on now against the probable next Prime Minister.

The protesters chose their pitch carefully. The site is a public area set back from the High Road. It once held the Station's Booking Office. When this was removed a wrought iron canopy was relocated here from Elstree Station. There are a few fixed chairs, used by folk to regard the local scene, but these were unavailable during the protest. There is also an old water fountain.

All this detail  is relevant, as the canopy posts plus water fountain plus a planter, enabled the protesters to unfurl a long physical banner and secure a boundary. You can argue that this was to prevent the crowd from leaking out into surrounding areas; you could also argue that it created a sense of territoriality, and if I were of the opposite persuasion I would have been reluctant to penetrate the cordon. 

Natasha's business is next to the pitch. She told the Jewish Chronicle that during the week the protesters damaged the stall's equipment, stole its electrical supply to use for their loudspeaker-driven chants and speeches, and on Thursday forced the stall to close. 

I was out of town for most of the week, but looked in late on Friday afternoon. The protesters were in situ and in full voice. They appeared well taught for their repertoire of chants: the old favourite of 'From the River to the Sea' appeared frequently, and amongst others I picked up was the to the point '5, 6, 7, 8, Israel is a terror state'. Nice.

Monitoring the action were ten or so police officers. They had little to do but stand around. What else they might otherwise have been doing to protect the public and combat crime I do not know.

Passers-by seemed mostly to ignore the protest, although I saw a hijab-clad woman with a placard being accosted by another woman as she walked down the road towards the group - the voice of the second woman indicated that she had had a few wines over the day. And in Pret there was an older man with a keffiyah draped around his neck, munching a sandwich and probably musing in his head about the spirit of '68.

Lawful protest? Who knows? The JC's article suggested that the protesters thought they had permission.

I spent 20 minutes by the stall, chatting to Natasha and her colleagues. The protest noise was unpleasant if not totally deafening. When the chanters paused to rest vocal cords, a drum struck up to maintain the momentum. 20 minutes was enough - it would have done my head in to be there much longer so I don't know how you could cope if you were trying to serve customers hour after hour...assuming that potential customers were not intimidated from flower-buying that day. Natasha said that her takings for the week were seriously down.

I did not need flowers, but tendered £20. Natasha's colleague insisted on picking out a bunch in return and delivering it across the road to the Assembly House pub.

Natasha made very plain that she takes no sides in the conflict - all she wants to do is run her business. I have written periodically on the conflict, mainly - for example An Unlikely Zion Sceptic -  to point out the complexities of the region's history and the futility of crass slogan-chanting. 

So to the question - was the injury last week to Natasha's business acceptable collateral damage in the pursuance of a higher cause? My answer is simple. No.

.........

The author is a writer, speaker, historian,, and former Managing Partner of a City law firm.